Child Support Vs Spousal Support - New California Divorce Law

A new California divorce law allows a spouse receiving income from child support to seek an increase in his or her spousal support upon the maturity of the minor child. This law, (Family Code 4326), which is set to terminate on January 1, 2011, considers the loss of child support income incurred by a parent when the child becomes no longer eligible for support, (e.g. reaches the age of 18 or graduates high school) to be a "change in circumstances" substantial enough to justify a request to modify their spousal support.

This new law presents a departure from prior court rulings. In a 1999 case, In re Marriage of Lautsbaugh (1999) 72 Cal.App.4th 1131, 85 Cal.Rptr.2d 688, a California Appeals Court reversed a decision granting a wife a $350 increase in her monthly support payments. The wife claimed such an increase was justified because her daughter had graduated from high school, and was no longer eligible for child support.

In reversing the trial court, the Court of Appeals reasoned that the loss of child support payments upon the daughter's reaching maturity was contemplated by both parties during the initial divorce proceedings and was therefore an expected change. The court went to state that a change previously accounted for, cannot justify an increase in spousal support. In the end, the court held that when the daughter graduated, her father's child support obligations terminated.

While the rationale of the Court of Appeals makes sense, the new law effectively nullifies Lautsbaugh and seemingly broadens the definition of a "material change" to include previously contemplated events. In addition, the provision interrelates the two types of support, which have been historically separate and should remain that way.

Although this current state of the law does not go so far as to require California family courts to now consider modifying a spouse's support anytime a change in financial status occurs, it definitely eases the burden of proof. Whether the parent will be required to show that their expenses, and not those of the child, justify a change in support, remains to be seen. Whatever the eventual outcome, Family Code 4326 will likely be a source of much debate in the coming years, especially if it remains in effect after January 2011. Indeed this law could have a large impact on child support in California.

Comments: [0] / Post comment:
30 Aug 2008 11:13:32

Romney backers throw support to Palin - Detroit Free Press

ABC News Romney backers throw support to Palin Detroit Free Press, United States - ... the candidate he supported in Michigan's primary, because he has heard so much support for the pair during his door-to-door campaigning. ... Video: Moms React To Palin Selection County's GOP leaders support McCain's pick Lubbock County Republicans Support McCain's Running Mate Choice -
30 Aug 2008 06:58:21

Inmet and Petaquilla Copper Sign Definitive Support Agreement - FOXBusiness

Inmet and Petaquilla Copper Sign Definitive Support Agreement FOXBusiness - Accordingly, the PTC Board of Directors has approved the entering into of the support agreement and recommends that PTC's shareholders accept the Offer. ...
30 Aug 2008 04:18:38

Operation HOPE Announces Support for the New FDIC Loan ... - MarketWatch

Operation HOPE Announces Support for the New FDIC Loan ... MarketWatch - ... that HOPE is in full support of the loss-mitigation plan announced recently by Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) Chairman Sheila C. Bair. ...

Keywords: